November 19, 2026 6 min read

A Co-Owner Is Hoarding: What Can Your Michigan Condo Board Legally Do?

What can a Michigan condo board do when a co-owner’s hoarding creates fire hazards, odors, or pests? The board can and should enforce its governing documents. But hoarding disorder can qualify as a disability under federal and Michigan fair housing law, so the board must consider a reasonable accommodation before it escalates enforcement.

For a community association board, few situations are as difficult as a resident living with severe clutter and unsanitary conditions. Boards have a fiduciary duty to protect property values, maintain health and safety standards, and enforce the governing documents. In a condominium, where units share walls, ceilings, and ventilation, one hoarded unit can put every neighbor at risk. Yet even when a unit is a genuine hazard, acting too quickly can turn a routine violation into a discrimination claim.

A recent decision from a Michigan federal court shows how that happens. In Rogan v Chateaufort Place Cooperative, Inc., unpublished opinion of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, issued June 23, 2026 (Case No. 25-cv-12443), the court allowed a resident’s fair housing claims to proceed against a housing cooperative that rejected his accommodation requests after obtaining an eviction judgment. Although Rogan involved a cooperative, the same fair housing rules apply to Michigan condominium and homeowners associations.

What Is Hoarding Disorder, and Why Does It Matter for Michigan Condos?

Hoarding is far more than messiness, poor housekeeping, or a reluctance to throw things away. The American Psychiatric Association has recognized hoarding disorder as a distinct psychiatric condition since 2013. People with hoarding disorder have ongoing trouble parting with their possessions, no matter what the items are worth, and become severely distressed at the thought of discarding them.

Over time, living areas can become so cluttered that rooms can no longer be used for their intended purposes. In a condominium community, that clutter often creates fire and safety hazards, pest problems, and sanitation issues that reach beyond the unit and into the common elements.

When Is Hoarding a Protected Disability Under Michigan and Federal Law?

Hoarding disorder can qualify as a disability under the federal Fair Housing Act, as amended by the Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988 (FHAA), 42 U.S.C. § 3601 et seq., and under the Michigan Persons with Disabilities Civil Rights Act, MCL 37.1101 et seq. When a resident’s violations of the governing documents are tied to a disability, the FHAA requires a community association to consider a reasonable accommodation. 42 U.S.C. § 3604(f)(3)(B).

A reasonable accommodation is a change to the association’s rules, policies, practices, or services that gives the resident an equal opportunity to use and enjoy the home. In practice, that means the board should pause standard enforcement long enough to evaluate an accommodation request rather than pressing ahead.

How a Michigan Co-op’s Hoarding Eviction Became a Fair Housing Lawsuit

In Rogan, a long-term Chateaufort Place resident with mobility issues and hoarding disorder suffered a medical emergency in 2023. He was hospitalized and in rehabilitation for three months. During that time, the cooperative entered his unit, discovered the clutter and a biohazard spill, and hired vendors to box up his belongings.

In early 2025, the cooperative issued violation notices for unsanitary housekeeping, clutter, and blocked exits and passageways. By March 2025, the board had started eviction proceedings in state court, and in May 2025 the state court entered an eviction judgment. After that, the resident’s neighbor petitioned for an emergency guardianship, and the resident was formally evaluated and diagnosed with hoarding disorder.

In June and July 2025, the resident, through his attorney, sent reasonable accommodation requests asking the board to stay the eviction and allow him to remain in his home. He presented proof that:

  1. The unit had been thoroughly cleaned and brought back into full compliance with the cooperative’s rules.
  2. A legal guardian and conservator were being appointed to keep the unit clean, safe, and compliant going forward.

The cooperative rejected the request as unreasonable, for three reasons. First, a clean unit today did not guarantee future compliance, given his medical condition. Second, it doubted that a guardian would solve the problem. Third, it argued the requests were invalid because they came after the eviction proceedings began and before his formal diagnosis.

The court disagreed. It denied the cooperative’s motion to dismiss and allowed the resident’s claims for discrimination, retaliation, and discriminatory statements to proceed. That ruling does not mean the cooperative is liable; it means the claims were strong enough to move forward. Separately, the resident succeeded in having the state court eviction judgment vacated on appeal.

Three Fair Housing Lessons From Rogan for Michigan Condo Boards

1. A “Second Chance” Can Be a Reasonable Accommodation

The court noted that requests for a “second chance” are routinely recognized as reasonable accommodations. That is especially true when a resident with a disability has corrected the violations and put safeguards in place to prevent them from recurring, such as medical treatment or a guardian.

2. A Formal Diagnosis Is Not Required Up Front

Under the FHAA, a resident does not need a formal medical diagnosis in hand at the moment he or she asks for an accommodation. If a community association has doubts, it may request supporting medical documentation. It cannot simply reject the request outright.

3. Litigation Does Not Erase the Board’s Fair Housing Duties

Even after an association starts eviction or other enforcement proceedings, it cannot automatically refuse to take part in the interactive accommodation process. A pending case is not a reason to stop listening to a resident who asks for an accommodation.

Key Takeaways: How Michigan Condo Boards Should Handle Hoarding

The lesson from Rogan is not that a community association is powerless to address hoarding. Boards do not have to tolerate genuine fire hazards, structural damage, or ongoing health threats to neighbors. You can, and should, act to enforce your governing documents and protect your community. But acting too quickly or too rigidly can turn a valid enforcement action into a costly discrimination claim.

When a board discovers severe clutter or hoarding in a unit, it should follow a measured, legally sound approach:

1. Document Objective Health and Safety Risks

Document specific, concrete violations of the governing documents, such as blocked doorways, fire hazards, odors, or pest issues. Keep written notes and photographs in the association’s records. Focus the documentation on facts, not on judgments about how the resident lives.

2. Treat Severe Hoarding as a Potential Disability From the Start

Severe hoarding is rarely a matter of a resident being stubborn. When the board encounters extreme clutter, it should treat the situation as a potential disability from the outset and plan its response with that in mind.

3. Engage With the Resident Before You Escalate

If a resident, family member, or advocate asks for time to clean the unit, proposes a remediation plan, or brings in a social worker or guardian, do not automatically say no. The board may ask for reasonable verification of the disability and for proof of the safeguards meant to keep the problem from returning. It can also set clear, firm compliance benchmarks, schedule periodic inspections, and put the agreed plan in writing.

4. Consult Community Association Counsel Early

Before beginning an eviction, lawsuit, or other enforcement action against a resident who may have hoarding disorder, review the timeline and accommodation options with your community association attorney.

Balancing Hoarding Enforcement and Fair Housing in Michigan Condominiums

Enforcing community standards and complying with fair housing law are not mutually exclusive. Michigan condo boards that pair firm safety expectations with a documented, good-faith accommodation process can resolve hazardous living conditions and keep the association out of federal court.

If your board is dealing with a hoarded unit or has received an accommodation request, contact the experienced Michigan community association attorneys at Hirzel Law before taking enforcement action.

Hirzel Law

Questions? We represent condo and HOA boards across Michigan.

(866) 394-4642Request a Proposal
Elizabeth Orsi
About the Author Elizabeth Orsi Associate Attorney
View Profile →

Elizabeth Orsi is an Associate Attorney in Hirzel Law’s litigation group, dually licensed in Michigan and the Province of Ontario, Canada. Before joining the firm, she handled litigation involving real estate disputes, business contracts, and landlord-tenant matters at law firms in Michigan and Ontario. She earned her Juris Doctor from the University of Detroit Mercy School of Law and the University of Windsor School of Law. Learn more on her full bio at hirzellaw.com.